What Warranty Company will say to avoid paying out - and how to repond
1. Its Wear & Tear - and as you're in the first 90 days of your policy, you're not covered
- this a great get-out clause for all policies that result in a claim in the first three months. They tried to use that when my engine seized at 65,000 miles. Thats right, a seized engine at 65,000 miles on a 5 year old car is due to wear & tear. We all instinctively know what wear & tear is. Its the stitching on your drivers side seat coming loose, or a bit of kerbing, or knackered brake pads. But what is it not? Well, its not a seized engine.
- Most legal definitions of wear & tear focus on landlord and tenant disputes, but the same principles apply. Reasonable wear and tear is generally defined as "unavoidable deterioration in the dwelling and its fixtures resulting from normal use". Is a rusting wheel arch, or greying plastic bumpers, unavoidable? yes. is a gearbox or engine failure on a relatively new and well serviced car unavoidable? no.
2. Its Pre-existing - and therefore not covered
- Superficially this is a completely legitimate clause and designed specifically to prevent people identifying a problem with their car, taking out an insurance policy and then claiming it went 'bang' while under warranty. No company should be liable for that, but unfortunately its also open to abuse by the companies it is supposed to protect. It means Warranty Company can get out of literally any claim they wish (unless they insured the car from new, which they didn't). Thats because every failure has a cause, and every cause may have begun 5 minutes ago or 5 years ago. You might reasonably ask yourself "how can they be so sure that its pre-existing?". Easy, they have a team of "independent" engineers working for them at companies like REDACTED who will be able to say, with confidence, that the fault definitely, DEFINITELY, pre-dates the policy. How can they be so sure? I'll let you draw your own conclusions. However, the report they produced about my car was plagiarised from a website on lubrication.
Helpfully, the Financial Ombudsman Service have some guidance:
- (https://www.financial-ombudsman.org.uk/publications/technical_notes/medical-conditions.htm).
Overview: An exclusion for pre-existing conditions is common in health-related insurance policies, such as private medical insurance and payment protection insurance (PPI). But the exclusion is also used in other policies - for example, pet insurance and travel insurance.
Our Approach: We usually decide that an insurer is not entitled to reject a claim on the basis of a pre-existing condition if the consumer did not know that they (or their relative or pet, if relevant) had a pre-existing condition.
3. Its consequential damage caused by an uninsured part
Imagine the scenario, a fuel feed pump comes loose and sets fire to your £200k Ferrari 458. You call Warranty Company and they (could) say, "sorry, we don't cover consumables, and the pipe is a consumable, so you're not covered". What i did was called up Warranty Company, and recorded the conversations i had with the sales agents. This proved that their sales staff will tell you one thing is covered, and their claims department will tell you something else.
4. Its not mechanical and therefore its not a breakdown
- It was quite a surprise to hear that my seized engine had not broken down. Because, you know, i was making a claim for a broken down engine. Anyhoo, Warranty Company seem to think it wasn't break-down. The reason? well, according to them a breakdown is "the sudden and unexpected failure of a part arising from any permanent mechanical, electrical or electronic fault". So, if the breakdown is caused by "a failure of lubrication" (their words) then its not mechanical, and therefore not covered. Was the failure of lubrication caused by a mechanical failure elsewhere? doesn't matter, apparently, still not covered. Presumably an overheating engine also wouldnt be covered as it was "a failure of the correct heat". Sound bonkers? it is. Thankfully the the Financial Ombudsman didn't buy this argument (nor would anyone with a brain). The Consumer Rights Act has something to say on the subject:
- Consumer Rights Act Schedule 2 Part 1 term 16 "a term which has the...effect of giving the trader the...exclusive right to interpret any term of a contract [is not legal]". In summary, a breakdown is exactly what you think it is, not what they tell you it is.
5. The breakdown isn't sudden
- Lets imagine you drive a car from Nice Airport to London Paddington without any problems. Lets imagine that shortly after you drop it off at the garage, they call to say the engine has seized. If you have any knowledge of cars you would probably think "an engine seizure is sudden, it cant seize slowly". Well, according to Warranty Company, you would be wrong. Thats because even though "the final failure" was sudden, the failure that lead to the "final failure" was not. Thats a convenient interpretation of the word "sudden". Fortunately, it doesn't stack-up and is also contrary to the Consumer Rights Act Schedule 2 Part 1 term 16 which i mention in the previous section. Also, the un-sudden failure wasnt spotted when it was serviced a month before the failure, examined by a specialist garage a week before the failure, and examined by another specialist half an hour before the failure.
6. You missed a service, you're not covered
- If Warranty Company discover your car has missed a service, they'll pin the cause of the failure on inadequate servicing. However, your car does not need to have a full service history. The only servicing requirements under their policy are as follows:
Are there any restrictions on cover?
The vehicle must have been serviced within the 12 months prior to the start date or been serviced to the manufacturer’s guidelines
So, all Warranty Company have to do to get out of a claim is point to the service interval of 11,000 miles rather than the manufacturer reccommendation of 10,000 miles and say "HA! You're service interval didnt follow manufacturer guidelines, thats EXACTLY why your engine blew up". Clearly, this is nonsense, which is why you need to follow the piece of advice in section 8.
7 - Your engine has been modified/remapped
OK, you cant get out of this one, and probably for good reason. If you've tinkered with your engine then that will invalidate any warranty. But you knew that.
8 - Finally, and most importantly, get yourself an Engineer!
Warranty Company have ongoing relationships with companies like REDACTED who have an incentive to conclude everything is either wear & tear, pre-existing, or some other rubbish. I'm not saying they do that, OBVIOUSLY, i'm just saying they have an incentive to do so. These are completely incompetent (as demonstrated by the fact the one who examined my car misunderstood evidence, didnt bother to take an oil sample, and then copied part of his report from a website he found on lubrication). It might cost you £6-700 but it will be worth it to confirm that any problem has nothing to do with inadequate servicing. You can find an engineer here: http://www.iaea-online.org/
Hope the above was helpful. If there are any other reasons they've given you for not paying out, comment below and i'll add them to this list
- this a great get-out clause for all policies that result in a claim in the first three months. They tried to use that when my engine seized at 65,000 miles. Thats right, a seized engine at 65,000 miles on a 5 year old car is due to wear & tear. We all instinctively know what wear & tear is. Its the stitching on your drivers side seat coming loose, or a bit of kerbing, or knackered brake pads. But what is it not? Well, its not a seized engine.
- Most legal definitions of wear & tear focus on landlord and tenant disputes, but the same principles apply. Reasonable wear and tear is generally defined as "unavoidable deterioration in the dwelling and its fixtures resulting from normal use". Is a rusting wheel arch, or greying plastic bumpers, unavoidable? yes. is a gearbox or engine failure on a relatively new and well serviced car unavoidable? no.
2. Its Pre-existing - and therefore not covered
- Superficially this is a completely legitimate clause and designed specifically to prevent people identifying a problem with their car, taking out an insurance policy and then claiming it went 'bang' while under warranty. No company should be liable for that, but unfortunately its also open to abuse by the companies it is supposed to protect. It means Warranty Company can get out of literally any claim they wish (unless they insured the car from new, which they didn't). Thats because every failure has a cause, and every cause may have begun 5 minutes ago or 5 years ago. You might reasonably ask yourself "how can they be so sure that its pre-existing?". Easy, they have a team of "independent" engineers working for them at companies like REDACTED who will be able to say, with confidence, that the fault definitely, DEFINITELY, pre-dates the policy. How can they be so sure? I'll let you draw your own conclusions. However, the report they produced about my car was plagiarised from a website on lubrication.
Helpfully, the Financial Ombudsman Service have some guidance:
- (https://www.financial-ombudsman.org.uk/publications/technical_notes/medical-conditions.htm).
Overview: An exclusion for pre-existing conditions is common in health-related insurance policies, such as private medical insurance and payment protection insurance (PPI). But the exclusion is also used in other policies - for example, pet insurance and travel insurance.
Our Approach: We usually decide that an insurer is not entitled to reject a claim on the basis of a pre-existing condition if the consumer did not know that they (or their relative or pet, if relevant) had a pre-existing condition.
3. Its consequential damage caused by an uninsured part
Imagine the scenario, a fuel feed pump comes loose and sets fire to your £200k Ferrari 458. You call Warranty Company and they (could) say, "sorry, we don't cover consumables, and the pipe is a consumable, so you're not covered". What i did was called up Warranty Company, and recorded the conversations i had with the sales agents. This proved that their sales staff will tell you one thing is covered, and their claims department will tell you something else.
4. Its not mechanical and therefore its not a breakdown
- It was quite a surprise to hear that my seized engine had not broken down. Because, you know, i was making a claim for a broken down engine. Anyhoo, Warranty Company seem to think it wasn't break-down. The reason? well, according to them a breakdown is "the sudden and unexpected failure of a part arising from any permanent mechanical, electrical or electronic fault". So, if the breakdown is caused by "a failure of lubrication" (their words) then its not mechanical, and therefore not covered. Was the failure of lubrication caused by a mechanical failure elsewhere? doesn't matter, apparently, still not covered. Presumably an overheating engine also wouldnt be covered as it was "a failure of the correct heat". Sound bonkers? it is. Thankfully the the Financial Ombudsman didn't buy this argument (nor would anyone with a brain). The Consumer Rights Act has something to say on the subject:
- Consumer Rights Act Schedule 2 Part 1 term 16 "a term which has the...effect of giving the trader the...exclusive right to interpret any term of a contract [is not legal]". In summary, a breakdown is exactly what you think it is, not what they tell you it is.
5. The breakdown isn't sudden
- Lets imagine you drive a car from Nice Airport to London Paddington without any problems. Lets imagine that shortly after you drop it off at the garage, they call to say the engine has seized. If you have any knowledge of cars you would probably think "an engine seizure is sudden, it cant seize slowly". Well, according to Warranty Company, you would be wrong. Thats because even though "the final failure" was sudden, the failure that lead to the "final failure" was not. Thats a convenient interpretation of the word "sudden". Fortunately, it doesn't stack-up and is also contrary to the Consumer Rights Act Schedule 2 Part 1 term 16 which i mention in the previous section. Also, the un-sudden failure wasnt spotted when it was serviced a month before the failure, examined by a specialist garage a week before the failure, and examined by another specialist half an hour before the failure.
6. You missed a service, you're not covered
- If Warranty Company discover your car has missed a service, they'll pin the cause of the failure on inadequate servicing. However, your car does not need to have a full service history. The only servicing requirements under their policy are as follows:
Are there any restrictions on cover?
The vehicle must have been serviced within the 12 months prior to the start date or been serviced to the manufacturer’s guidelines
So, all Warranty Company have to do to get out of a claim is point to the service interval of 11,000 miles rather than the manufacturer reccommendation of 10,000 miles and say "HA! You're service interval didnt follow manufacturer guidelines, thats EXACTLY why your engine blew up". Clearly, this is nonsense, which is why you need to follow the piece of advice in section 8.
7 - Your engine has been modified/remapped
OK, you cant get out of this one, and probably for good reason. If you've tinkered with your engine then that will invalidate any warranty. But you knew that.
8 - Finally, and most importantly, get yourself an Engineer!
Warranty Company have ongoing relationships with companies like REDACTED who have an incentive to conclude everything is either wear & tear, pre-existing, or some other rubbish. I'm not saying they do that, OBVIOUSLY, i'm just saying they have an incentive to do so. These are completely incompetent (as demonstrated by the fact the one who examined my car misunderstood evidence, didnt bother to take an oil sample, and then copied part of his report from a website he found on lubrication). It might cost you £6-700 but it will be worth it to confirm that any problem has nothing to do with inadequate servicing. You can find an engineer here: http://www.iaea-online.org/
Hope the above was helpful. If there are any other reasons they've given you for not paying out, comment below and i'll add them to this list
Comments
Post a Comment